Luke Surl Comics

The latest from LukeSurl.com
‹
›
  • archive
  • About
  • Extras
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter2
''So, you're applying for the job of the guard who always lies?'' ''No.''
First Previous Random 9Comments Subscribe Next Latest
TIP: You can use the 'Z' (back) and 'C' (forward) keyboard buttons to navigate the comic archive.

236 – Guards! Guards!

by Luke on November 18, 2009 at 12:00 am

Discussion (9) ¬

[ Comments RSS ]
  1. Jack Aviado
    Jack Aviado
    November 18, 2009 at 4:29 am | # | Reply

    Lovely. I’ve always liked that puzzle. See http://jack.is/puzzled/fork.php
    Though I never imagine I’ll grasp it entirely. ;)

  2. Timm
    Timm
    November 18, 2009 at 8:50 pm | # | Reply

    … me too :)

  3. MrGBH
    MrGBH
    November 18, 2009 at 10:02 pm | # | Reply

    Easy, just ask one if his route is safe. After he answers, shoot him in the foot, then note their responses.

    • Luke
      Luke
      November 18, 2009 at 10:13 pm | # | Reply

      heh I know where you got that from

  4. x
    x
    November 19, 2009 at 9:41 pm | # | Reply

    buh? “ouch” neither qualifies as lie, nor as truth…

    • Philip
      Philip
      March 2, 2010 at 8:07 pm | # | Reply

      “He shot you/me in the foot!” “No, he didn’t!”.

      That is, assuming they are capable of experiencing pain and not just, for the riddle’s sake, only capable of responding to your question before turning to stone, shutting down, or whatever.

  5. Gavin C. Stewart
    Gavin C. Stewart
    February 26, 2010 at 8:27 pm | # | Reply

    Haha, the Corporaco logo is on his sheild

  6. Programmer
    Programmer
    June 14, 2011 at 3:49 am | # | Reply

    This answer always confused because of variable(memory) (unless you always make the lying one answer first).
    This might be hard to explain, but I will try.
    In programming you make variables called Person1 and Person2. Then ask the question. If Person1 is the truthful one and says right, then it is recorded in the variable. When Person2, who lies, looks at the answer recorded for Person1 and will say the opposite, left, and record that in the variable. Hence it will have opposite answers like any other question.
    However, I guess you can assume and make the variables constants, therefore solving the variable problem. This means you would have to question them without them know what the other person has said currently (like in different rooms), or not have them pay attention to the other person’s answer. Though if they are apart they would have to assume what the other person would say.

    *sigh* I think too much sometimes…

  7. Me
    Me
    December 19, 2011 at 7:12 pm | # | Reply

    A slight variation:
    http://xkcd.com/246/

Comment ¬
Cancel reply

@lukesurl on Twitter

    Luke Surl
    Norwich, UK

  • http://t.co/fkatzQaY
    2012/05/16
  • On behalf of Greater Anglia Travel I would like to take this opportunity to KABOOM
    2012/05/14
  • Ladies and gentlemen, we will shortly be arriving in NORWICH where this train will SELF-DESTRUCT.
    2012/05/14
  • Fun day at #BristolExpo today. Most of what I made selling I've spent on comics myself - got some interesting titles to read on the train!
    2012/05/13
  • A replacement bus service is in operation. We apologise for any disruption this may cause to your journey.
    2012/05/13

Most Shared Comics

  • 380 – Picking up the pieces
  • 187 – An unequal relationship?
  • 280 – Calvinism (but no Hobbes)
  • 366 – Baby got back
  • 317 – Blessed are the pawn in spirit

Comics by email:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Tag cloud

Animals Heart Computers Video Games Shakespeare Space Love Christmas Nursery Rhymes physics Pirates Evolution Facebook Math CCTV Film murder Court songs Pop Music Musicals Vampires Psychiatrist Economy Drugs Hamlet music Medical Art Zombies Police Fish Ocean crime Wizard of Oz Death Internet Chess Cavemen Mathematics Grammar Health star trek sea Science Superheroes Superman Rock Literature Politics time travel Poetry chemistry Mythology philosophy Maths Twitter Graphs Magic Religion

©2008-2012 Luke Surl | Powered by WordPress with ComicPress | Subscribe: RSS | Back to Top ↑